Fox Makes Out Like Bandit With 'Idol' and Bowl

Strike-Proof Programs Put Net in Catbird Seat Heading Into Next Year

By Published on .

NEW YORK ( -- The writers strike and the decline of broadcast-TV ratings have got plenty of network executives down. Not Peter Chernin.
Photo: Fox

Peter Chernin, president, News Corp.

More Info:

Who's Buying What in the Super Bowl
A Rundown of Marketers and Their Spots in the Big Game

The News Corp. president is one media-company executive who has reason to smile. With Fox readying its singing-contest juggernaut "American Idol" for January and the Super Bowl airing in February, the network is in the strongest position going into 2008. With double-digit cost-per-thousand price increases for scatter, Super Bowl prices at an all-time high -- $2.7 million to $3 million for a 30-second spot -- and marketers jonesing for TiVo-proof TV, Fox looks set to have a very fine first quarter.

The writers strike threatens to continue into 2008, thwarting networks' chances of keeping their best ratings grabbers -- dramas and comedies -- on the air. In fact, the strike should work in favor of "Idol," which started to show some wear last season, as advertisers focus their attention on the few programs sure to draw viewers. "When ... everyone is simply repeating old shows or experimenting with new reality shows, this show just increases its potential to really take share," said Michael Nathanson, a Sanford C. Bernstein analyst.

Live draw
Audience levels for network TV have been eroding for years, and the strike could accelerate that trend. Consumers are already growing more resistant to traditional advertising, and the strike threatens to add a healthy portion of viewer disillusionment to the mix. So the attraction for the gridiron classic and "Idol" makes sense; a prolonged strike means there will be fewer properties people want to watch in prime time, and many will opt instead to watch hours or days later online or on a DVR. Viewers are more likely to tune in for live events when the networks air them.

No surprise, then, that Fox's programming is pricey. A few Super Bowl berths have commanded unprecedented rates of up to $3 million, and with few spots left, Fox is looking to peddle the last ones for even more than that. Media buyers have said the cost of a 30-second ad in "Idol" ranges from $500,000 to more than $700,000, depending on when in the program's seasonal arc it runs (the last few episodes are must-see events). Fox still has limited inventory to sell, media buyers said, but it likely will come at a premium. (See which marketers have already bought into the game.)

Still king of mass reach
Regardless of its rocky season, broadcast TV remains the best way for marketers to blast branding and sales messages to the greatest number of consumers in a single swoop. Coca-Cola's strategy -- which includes ads and integration with "Idol" and Super Bowl advertising -- is emblematic of what other marketers might seek as the environment worsens. Coke looks for alliances with properties that are hard to miss, including NCAA basketball and Nascar, said Dan Donnelly, senior VP-group director at MediaVest, who supervises media spending for Coke. "With all the talk of a strike, we're pretty comfortable with what we have," he said.

Because "Idol" will stand out during a prolonged strike, media buyers are asking whether Fox would consider adding another half-hour or even another night of the program to its schedule. So far, Fox is telling everyone no.

"They don't want to kill the golden goose," one media buyer said. "I wouldn't be surprised if [adding 'Idol' programming] is what they ended up doing, but I'm sure they won't look to flood the market," Mr. Donnelly said. A Fox spokesman declined to comment.
In this article:
Most Popular