CANNES WINNER QUESTIONED AS POSSIBLE SCAM

Johnson & Johnson Denies It Retained Agency

By Published on .

RIO DE JANEIRO (AdAgeGlobal.com) -- A black cloud may be darkening for Brazilian independent DPZ Propaganda's double victory in Cannes last week.

The agency's two Gold Lions (for Press & Poster and Cyber), picked up for Johnson & Johnson's lubricant gel KY, are being discredited by the client. McCann-Erickson Worldwide has been Johnson & Johnson's agency for KY for the past three years.

Client denial
In a statement, Johnson & Johnson said, "[The print ad] was created without the involvement or approval of any of [the company's] employees."

It continues: "The company also informs that this account has been at McCann-Erickson for over three years."

DPZ declined to comment.

This appears to be the first major 'scam ad' of the 2002 International

Related Stories:
THE GHOST ADS OF CANNES
Scam Entries Haunt Festival, Threaten Credibility
TWO GOLD LION FINALISTS DISQUALIFIED AS SCAMS
"Clear Violation of the Rules" Says Jury President
Advertising Festival at Cannes.

Festival precautions
The previous year, the company that owns the world's premier advertising festival and its judges became obsessed with stamping out scam ads.

A scam ad can include an ad that was never approved by a client or an ad that ran once in order to technically qualify for an advertising contest.

Last year Cannes officials were on the lookout for scam ads because of several embarrassments from the 2000 festival. That year, Lowe Lintas & Partners Worldwide, Sydney, returned a Bronze Lion for a print ad after the Taronga Zoo said it had rejected the winning ad because it portrayed animals in a manner contrary to the zoo's ethos. The agency returned a second Bronze Lion for a TV spot for Atrel Australia's plastic containers.

Ghosts
Scam ads are not new. They are know as "truchos" in Spanish, and Brazilians call them "fantasmas" or ghost ads.

This year, DPZ's Rio de Janeiro office picked up a Gold Lion Press Award in the health and beauty section and a Gold Cyber Lion Award in the rich media banners section. Both were for Johnson & Johnson's KY Jelly product.

DPZ, headquartered in Sao Paulo, courted controversy in Brazil five years ago when it created a commercial for Johnson & Johnson's Jontex condoms featuring a father and son discussing the younger man's sexual relationship with another man.

In this article:
Most Popular