MINI-REVIEW

Published on .

Joop jeans doesn't put its ideas on one leg at a time in a new magazine and outdoor campaign from Backer Spielvogel Bates/New York. Photography by Scott Morgan.

Chuck Finkle/Art Director

Goldsmith/Jeffrey, New York Applause for doing something different; boos for doing something different only for the sake of being different. Although this use of a child-as-Wonder Dog to sell jeans doesn't sink to the level of using a man dying of AIDS to sell sweaters, it relies on the same sort of non-idea: a shocking visual that has nothing to do with the product, and a logo stuck at the bottom. Admittedly, this is a tough category, but an idea would have worked far better than just a thought.

A little research among parents might also have revealed that comparing the housebreaking of Fido to the exhausting, exhilarating, mind-stretching job of raising a child was also just plain thoughtless.

Karin Onsager-Birch/Art Director

Goodby, Berlin & Silverstein, S.F. This is fun-looking, but at closer glance I find the line pretty degrading and the sub-line terribly unimportant. The ad makes me think Joop is a stupid company trying to be cute.

Barb Paulini/Senior Art Director

Hoffman York & Compton,Milwaukee My mother, who never put me on a leather-collar leash; who knew that a retouched shadow under a baby shouldn't look like a starfish; who knew the difference between a great stripping job and a cut and paste; who knew how to punctuate a headline; and who, above all, knew a good idea when she saw one, always told me, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all."

Tim Bauer/Senior Writer

GSD&M, Austin

I saw a cool layout and read the line and was sold. Then I found out they weren't selling flying babies. Too bad, because as a jeans ad it's pretty dumb. I'm supposed to relate to the thought, think the company really knows me, and let all that good will rub off on the product.

In this article:
Most Popular