P&G banner ads linking to Olean and Sunny Delight Web sites appear on search services Excite and WebCrawler, and the marketer is close to a deal to place ads on Parent Soup, a family-oriented site from iVillage. Yahoo! was the first to sell ads to P&G (AA, April 22).
P&G shook up the Web marketplace when it said it would only buy ads if a site changed its pricing plan from the current cost per impression model to a cost per click model.
"Instead of looking at impression, impression, impression, the ultimate objective is traffic," said Jeff Mallett, senior VP-business operations at Yahoo!.
P&G ads will appear on Yahoo! for about three months; the marketer also will start a promotion on Yahoo!'s home page, Mr. Mallett said.
In at least one case, P&G appears to be moderating its stance.
iVillage Senior VP-Market Development Robert Levitan said his pending deal with P&G will combine elements of the site's current impression-based model and P&G's click-through demand.
iVillage expects to achieve a premium of 15% on the deal over typical impression pricing, Mr. Levitan said. Ads on Parent Soup cost $75,000 for six months, or 4.4 cents per impression.
P&G and its interactive buying agency, Grey Advertising, New York, declined to comment.
All of the sites say their work with P&G is experimental and they have no intention of changing their entire pricing model.
"A percentage of our unsold inventory is available for alternative or experimental [ad] models," said Rick Vorhaus, director of advertising at Excite, comparing P&G's Web buy to late-night TV direct response commercials.
But such TV time is sold cheaply, the opposite of the highly targeted, premium pricing most Web publishers want for selling on a click-through basis.
Agency executives say if P&G gets special treatment, they want it also. "If you play ball with them, I expect the same treatment," said John Nardone, director of media and research services, Modem Media, Westport, Conn.