Once registered, you can:

  • - Read additional free articles each month
  • - Comment on articles and featured creative work
  • - Get our curated newsletters delivered to your inbox

By registering you agree to our privacy policy, terms & conditions and to receive occasional emails from Ad Age. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Are you a print subscriber? Activate your account.

TV Upfront

Ad Age Picks the Best and Worst TV Shows for Fall

Stick With 'X Factor' and 'Prime Suspect' but Skip the Grimm Stuff

By Published on .

"The X Factor" (Fox, Wednesday and Thursday): It looks like "American Idol," it features two judges from "Idol" and it's already a big hit overseas. Most new TV shows are a gamble, but advertisers think "X" truly marks the spot this fall.

'Prime Suspect'
'Prime Suspect' Credit: Patrick Harbron/NBC

"Prime Suspect" (NBC, Thursday): A remake of a popular British cop show, "Suspect" has a lot going for it. Maria Bello is recognized as an actress with integrity; the program looks to explore a bevy of hot-button issues; and it is the kind of high-quality drama NBC once routinely aired at 10 p.m.

"Suburgatory" (ABC, Wednesday): With a little luck, this clever drama about a teenage girl navigating between high-school cliques and an overprotective father could be another "Mean Girls."

HONORABLE MENTION: Sarah Michelle Gellar returns to TV in the intriguing CW drama "Ringer" and CBS has high hopes for female odd-couple comedy "2 Broke Girls."

HOW'D WE DO LAST YEAR? Awful. We thought Fox flop "Lone Star" would be a hit, and got suckered into believing in the power of Twitter with CBS's "$#*! My Dad Says." Only CW's "Nikita" is sticking around for another season.

"Charlie's Angels" (ABC, Thursday): If TV viewers really wanted more "Charlie's Angels," then Fox wouldn't have failed to revive the show in 1988 and 1989 and there would have been a third big-screen "CA" entry. This ABC remake looked soulless and tired.

'Once Upon a Time '
'Once Upon a Time ' Credit: Craig Sjodin/ABC

"Grimm" (NBC, Friday) and "Once Upon a Time " (ABC, Sunday): Does the world need two dramas about fairy-tale characters entering the real world? The premise of these two shows seem overly complex and best suited to comic-book fans, who might like more violence and flash than Hansel and Gretel.

"Are You There Vodka? It's Me, Chelsea" (NBC, mid-season): We know Chelsea Handler is wildly popular and works for NBC sibling network E!, but you can't build a sitcom on corporate synergy. This sitcom had a hangover, and a ready cure may not be available.

HOW'D WE DO LAST YEAR? Two for three. Fox's "Mixed Signals" and NBC's "Perfect Couples" were largely non-starters, while ABC's "Happy Endings" turned a tough-luck late-season start into a good launch. It will return next season.

Most Popular