November 24, 2009
Login | Register Now

Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News


More from Ad Age:
Creativity
Ad Age China
Bookstore
Jobs
Ad Age On Campus
Sign up for E-mail Newsletters

Stay on top of the news, sign up for our free newsletters


Diversity Programs Work ... And They're Necessary

The Reports of the Death of Diversity Have Been Greatly Exaggerated

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Submit to Digg Add to Google Share on StumbleUpon Submit to LinkedIn Add to Newsvine Bookmark on Del.icio.us Submit to Reddit

Tiffany Warren Tiffany R. Warren
I, like many others, took pause after reading the Wall Street Journal editorial page deputy editor Daniel Henninger declare that diversity is dead. His unsettling declaration is based on the findings of a recent Harvard University study by Professor Robert Putnam. I fervently disagree. Diversity, in fact, is not dead and is the very thing that breathed life into not only my education but also my career.

To provide perspective as to why my commitment for equality in all its forms (employment, GLBT, marketing, compensation) in advertising runs so deep, allow me to share with you my journey and why diversity programs are not a hand out but a hand up.

Thirty-three years ago my mother set aside her dreams in order to make mine come true.

When I was three years old, she enrolled me in St. James Head Start, a government sponsored program that gave multicultural, inner-city children in Boston a solid foundation to succeed in kindergarten and beyond. She then enrolled me in The Fresh Air Fund, where I spent a summer as a 3 ½-year old in Maine. In order to advance my education, she enrolled me in advance 4th and 5th grade classes at Curtis Guild Elementary School in East Boston miles from my home in Roxbury. In order to manifest the dreams she privately held for me, she urged me to apply to The Winsor School, where I received 100% financial aid for seven years and became part of the biggest incoming class of Black students in Winsor's history. I was one of five Black girls out of sixty White girls.

During my senior year, my mother helped me fill out my application for Inroads, where I spent three summers as a marketing intern for Verizon. During my last year in college, I attended a presentation by Elizabeth Talerman, an AEF speaker, who was a group director on CVS at Ingalls, Quinn and Johnson. Elizabeth became one of my earliest mentors and encouraged me to apply to a new program funded by The Ad Club of Boston. Because of Elizabeth, I became absolutely certain that the advertising industry is where I belonged and I left Inroads where I was making $8,000 per summer (far more than I would have earned as a summer intern in advertising) to become part of the first group of interns to receive The Arnold Rosoff Ad Club Foundation scholarship. This scholarship program was founded in honor of Arnold Z. Rosoff, founder of Arnold Worldwide. As an Ad Club Foundation intern, I spent my last summer in college as a traffic intern at Ingalls, Quinn and Johnson. I had the best summer of my life and Bink Garrison, CEO of IQ&J, assured me I had a bright future in the business. At the end of my internship, I was nominated for and became part of the first class of the AAF Promising Minority Students Program. The following year I started my first job in advertising at Hill Holliday.

At every turn during the last thirty years, diversity programs provided me with an opportunity to succeed but I could not have succeeded if I was not prepared. People have often said to me, "You are so lucky!" If "lucky" means I was prepared to take advantage of opportunities that came my way then I accept that I am lucky.

As a beneficiary of diversity programs, I have had to sacrifice a lot but in the end my "luck" provided me with the opportunities of a lifetime that in turn assured me a lifetime of opportunities.
4 Comments
Subscribe to comments on: Diversity Programs Work ... And They're Necessary
  By l | minneapolis, MN August 27, 2007 09:14:22 am:
Great article. Great points. Great examples. Keep it up!
  By lchampion2312 | HIlliard, OH August 27, 2007 10:38:35 am:
Wonderful article. Keep up the good work!
  By egbell | Southfield, MM August 27, 2007 11:01:33 am:
Success is where opportunity and preparation meet, regardless of the race. I agree.

In addition to the excellent point you make regarding the above, our reality is( for any minority, women included):

1) There is a powerful mindset that does not care about fairness only that they maintain a lifestyle advantage (financial, education, social, etc.)

2)At an accelerated pace, diversity programs are either not supported, reviewed for effectiveness or simply "show pieces" only (like ADs places in "Ebony" shouting we care). Any entity that has a diversity program (which is a good thing) implies: a) It is trying to right the wrongs of the past, b) It is trying to prevent racial/gender inequalities that are current within its operations or c)both of the above.

3) They see the laziness of only a "sub-set" of my race's population (Afri. Ameri.) that has opted not to aggressively utilize the benefits other DIED for on our behalf, as a reason to write the entire race off. The "laziness" is due to destruction of our family unit (50%/ 50% societal ills, gov't etc.) We need to fix our 50% so the world can clearly see the remaining 50% for what it is #1 above).

The reality for many minorities is "they want our money, without having to be in our preseence."

Collectively, when we decide to recognize these realities and get down to business with productive solutions within our communities and our families first, only then will we be taken more seriously...and there will be no need for diversity programs.

Aptitude and Attitude is what all minorities have, our cultures have exhibited it throughout history but we need to remind them in our present. This is what we need to demonstrate to the world...consistently.
  By gowi | Glenn Heights, TX August 27, 2007 11:03:47 pm:
I am not so sure that the Putnam research is entirely accurate in its findings of apathy and distrust (a bit of oversimplification)because it does not begin early enough to account for the difference that exposure, discipline and encouragement would make in the lives of our children.


The study focuses of the results of upbringing. Once those filters are set, then religion, politics and other "higher" unifying causes (money) are the only avenues for bringing diverse cultures together.


Diversity, in its true form will never be dead. How we perceive diversity will never be a dead topic. I will admit that some programs are contrived, trite and forced. However, I am not so sure I am willing to apologize for that given the historical treatment of minorities and especially Black people in the United States and even more so in Corporate America. As a Black man, I am forced to conform, in a different way than my white counterparts, everyday in some shape, form or fashion to the standards that . This is not an angry point, just one of reality. Also, people can change through forced education. Slavery taught us that.


I understand that Henninger writes that those who espouse diversity have not leveraged the true strengths and have reduced it to forced "feel good" training. He has a point. Diversity has been misused and misapplied. Diversity will never be dead, just look all around you.




Stay on top of the news and stay ahead of the game—sign up for e-mail newsletters now!



Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News