blog info popup

Author

Bob Garfield

Anthropology of Ad Agency Summed Up in 2 Minutes Flat

Ad for FITC Design & Technology Festival Sums Up Chaos Scenario in Far Less Than 90,000 Words

"The Last Advertising Agency on Earth" is a two-minute video about a fictional agency called MPS&C, which held a death grip on the status quo until one day it simply ceased being.

Full Article 1 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Garfield Says Adieu, AdReview

After 25 Years, Ad Age's Iconic Critic Is Hanging up His Stars, but Not Before Recalling His Hits and Misses -- and Yes, Having the Last Word

I'm retiring from AdReview for a lot of reasons, converging more or less by coincidence on my silver jubilee.

Full Article 46 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Mooncup Makes Sure Your Lady Parts Are Feeling the Love

LoveYourVagina.com Sells This Feminine Device Without Pussyfooting the Issue

How are you feeling about your vagina these days? We ask not without reason. LoveYourVagina.com is the website of a British product called Mooncup, which is a silicone receptacle designed to replace tampons and sanitary pad. These folks don't want you to be vaginally satisfied. They want amor.

Full Article 3 Comments
Author

Abbey Klaassen

Bob Garfield Set to Retire His Weekly Ad Review

Will Write New 'Listenomics' Column for Ad Age

NEW YORK (AdAge.com) -- Next month, after 25 years as the ad industry's preeminent critic, Bob Garfield will retire his weekly ad reviews in Advertising Age to take on two new enterprises.

Full Article 12 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

If Seeing Is Believing, Sharp Is Not So Bright in Its Messaging

In New Spot for TV With Extra Color, McGarryBowen Comes Close to Admitting Paradox of Advertising a TV on a TV

The new Quattron commercial from Sharp not only makes little attempt to demonstrate the product difference, it comes within a whisker of self-consciously pointing up the absurdity of attempting to demonstrate the product difference.

Full Article 19 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Treatment for Couple's Pain Makes Laughter Conceivable

Pharma Marketing Is a Less-Than-Noble Art, but This Infertility Drug Ad Is Amusing and Sympathetic

This is about a funny, knowing and smart direct-to-consumer drug campaign now being tested in Baltimore. But first, just a quick reminder that pharma marketing is a cesspool.

Full Article 7 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Devo's Postmodern Album Promo Hits All the Right Notes

Art Band Is Either Rethinking Its Identity or Ridiculing Crowdsourcing. Or Both

Is it even advertising? Who the hell knows? But it is so cool and funny and wicked and surprising and surprisingly restrained and postmodern in the best sense. In short: so Devo.

Full Article 8 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Part Flo, Part Dos Equis, This Insurance Ad Is Only Part Good

Nationwide Executives Persuade the World's Greatest Spokesperson in the World to Return

Advertising is permitted to mate a donkey with a horse and sell the client a mule. The "World's Greatest Spokesperson in the World" is a nice enough mule. It's not mule-tastic. It's not "mule die laughing." But it is an amusing, benefit-laden, altogether satisfactory mule.

Full Article 16 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

The Ad Review Super Bowl FAQ

Some Readers and Online Commentators Had Questions (and Insults) for Bob Garfield

Bob Garfield took the time to address a few points about this year's Super Bowl Ad Review.

Full Article 2 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Finalement, Our Long-Awaited Take on Google's Super Bowl Ad

Sergey and Co. Scrounge Up Some Change for a Charm Offensive

Apparently Sergey Brin and friends came up with two or three million dollars and used the Super Bowl to mount a charm offensive. Naturally, like everything else Google does, it was perfect.

Full Article 11 Comments

VIDEO: Bob Garfield Reviews the Super Bowl Spots

The Big Game's Best and Worst Ads ... and the Mostly Meh in Between

NEW YORK (AdAge.com) -- Advertising Age's ad critic, Bob Garfield, found this year's Super Bowl spots to be a whole lot of meh. Garfield gives us his take on Anheuser-Busch's lack of laughs in its lineup, takes Doritos -- and its consumers -- to task for its user-generated spots and heaps praise on his three favorite spots.

Full Article 16 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Watch This Spot and Then Tell Me That Unicorns Aren't Real

Walmart Ditches Schmaltz for the Hilarious Indignities of Real Life

Walmart, hitherto often a purveyor of treacle and dubiously Walmart-centric vignettes, has found real life -- in equal measures excruciating and hilarious.

Full Article 13 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Target Wins the Big Award for Witty, Wordy White Noise

Despite the Presence of Alan Cox and a Near-Universal Conundrum, These Offbeat Ads Fall Flat

New Target ads featuring Alan Cox are a sterling example of how colorful, witty, unusual, cheeky, intelligent advertising featuring a talented actor can be terrible at selling stuff to the people with the money.

Full Article 5 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Census Ads Are Misguided, Misleading and Miss The Point

We Love Christopher Guest, but the Upper West Side Isn't Exactly a Cross-Section of America

Having seen much of the ad and PSA campaign for the 2010 U.S. Census, the AdReview team has so many disconnected misgivings that the best we can do is blurt them out ad hoc, like someone coming out of anesthesia, or talk radio.

Full Article 19 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Domino's Does Itself a Disservice by Coming Clean About Its Pizza

We Like Apologies and Honesty, but There Are Limits. Just Ask Ford

To begin the new year, Domino's bought millions of dollars of advertising to announce to the world -- are you ready for this? -- how horrible its product has been for the past 40 years

Full Article 66 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

The Bobby Awards

Garfield Hands Out the 2009 Honors for Actors and Actresses in Commercials

Regrettably, in another down year for advertising creative worldwide, 2009 didn't yield exactly a bumper crop of nominees, but those actors and actresses who have been recognized for their performances are worthy, every single one.

Full Article 1 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Book of Tens: Ads Garfield Scorned in 2009

What campaigns did our resident ad critic bash for 2009? From Teleflora's ugly Super Bowl ad to AT&T's embarrassing response to Verizon, here's the worst of 2009.

Full Article 2 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Book of Tens: Ads Garfield Admired in 2009

From the Expense-a-Steak online expense-report generator from Maloney & Porcelli to Post cereal's inspired move for good old Shredded Wheat, here are the campaigns our ad critic loved in 2009.

Full Article 8 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Why Method Did Right in Pulling the Plug on 'Shiny Suds'

A Lesson in How Advertising Is About the Entire Audience

In an editorial elsewhere in the issue this week, Ad Age rolls its eyes at Method's decision to pull its online-video ad "Shiny Suds" -- or at least the culture of grievance that spawned it. AdReview respectfully disagrees

Full Article 24 Comments
Author

Bob Garfield

Dirty Politics Won't Help AT&T Win Votes in Race vs. Verizon

IPhone Carrier Uses Ugly 'Fact' Tactics in Latest Spot

One of the very best things about consumer advertising is that it isn't political advertising.

Full Article 14 Comments