November 23, 2009
Login | Register Now

Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News


More from Ad Age:
Creativity
Ad Age China
Bookstore
Jobs
Ad Age On Campus
Sign up for E-mail Newsletters

Stay on top of the news, sign up for our free newsletters


10 Reasons Your Company Shouldn't Blog

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Submit to Digg Add to Google Share on StumbleUpon Submit to LinkedIn Add to Newsvine Bookmark on Del.icio.us Submit to Reddit

B.L. Ochman B.L. Ochman also writes the popular What's Next Blog.
With alarming regularity, most recently Wednesday, I get inquiries from companies who want me to create a blog for them -- usually for the CEO. And nine out of 10 times, I talk them out of it.

The top 10 reasons I tell companies not to blog are:

1. The blogs most companies want to create are guaranteed to join the 900,999 out of every million blogs with no readers. Why? They're boring.


2. A blog has to have a personal voice. If you sound like a corporate drone, nobody will read your blog.

3. You need original content. The blogosphere is too much of an echo chamber already. What can you add that/s original? Or significantly better than anything else in your niche?

4. Blogging takes time -- lots of it. Let's even say a CEO is a great writer, who enjoys researching and crafting posts. And let's say he or she will write about what people want to hear about and not just write about what the company wants to say. And they he/she is willing to update a few times a week. All of that takes anywhere from two to four hours a post.

5. You need to read constantly to be a good blogger. That includes blogs, but also media outside the blogosphere -- feeds, forums, mainstream media -- so you can keep your readers informed about your topics.

6. A blog is not a substitute for a marketing campaign. It is simply a potential part of corporate communications.

7. A blog is not a substitute for advertising -- if you need to fill a new hotel, or sell a product by a certain date, advertise.

8. A blog is not a quick fix -- the results come in the long term, the same way they do with PR.

9. Blogs are not cheap. A good one requires skilled programming to set it up, a professional graphic designer to make it part of your corporate identity, a talented and dedicated writer or editor, full-time.

10. You need to drive traffic to a blog. There are many ways to do that. All of them require time, effort and money. Ways to drive traffic to a corporate blog include:
  • Advertising on blogs, where you can be incredibly niche specific and cost-effective; buying Google keywords; and including your URL in traditional and online advertising.
  • Promotion -- you can drive traffic to a blog with skillful promotion though other blogs, by becoming a respected part of social networking communities frequented by your customers; with contests, viral marketing, and the use of a variety of Web 2.0 promotional methods discussed frequently here and in other blogs that cover social media marketing.
16 Comments
Subscribe to comments on: 10 Reasons Your Company Shouldn't Blog
  By michaelgass | ALABASTER, AL September 22, 2008 01:21:48 pm:
Just wanted to say that I enjoyed this post. I'll provide a mention and link to it for my readers on FUEL LINES. I see these same reasons should be applied to ad agency blogs. They shouldn't do it if they are not willing to do it correctly by having the right motive, time and effort required to make them successful with their target audience.
  By BL | NEW YORK, NY September 22, 2008 03:26:50 pm:
Michael - thanks for the shout out on your blog (I subscribed to your feed.)

Sadly, ad agencies generally range from heavy handed to totally clueless when it comes to advising or creating clients' blogs.

And you are so very right that successful blogging takes a lot of time and effort for the long haul.
  By ADMAVEN | Chicago, IL September 22, 2008 05:38:36 pm:
I wanted to take a moment and say that I enjoyed the post, and I found your advice to be applicable to a wider audience than corporations. Individuals must also realize that their content needs to be relevant, informative, and entertaining to become popular.

I must add, however, that you should not discourage corporations OR individuals from starting their own blog. Companies make decisions - some good some bad - and then execute a plan. When the plan goes poorly (i.e. a blog with no readers) they look to either fix or terminate the program. If they terminate, then the point of your article is fulfilled. If they choose to improve, they may hire a skilled professional to take up the charge; producing both a job and meaningful content that is useful to end users.

I think your article is a poignant reminder of how NOT to write a blog, but don't you think the community at large would be better served by encouraging everyone to blog - but to do so correctly - as opposed to making blogging out to be a $100,000 per year plus corporate endeavor fraught with pitfalls and problems for already busy executives?

When I started my blog (http://admaven.blogspot.com) three months ago I had little content to offer. I have since improved and so has my readership, but I did so through first trying with poor results. If I had never tried at all I would have no blog and some readers who enjoy my content would not have had the chance to do so.

I have spend only time on the blog, yet have garnered what I consider to be success and fulfillment of a mission to establish my own identity in the Web 2.0 world as well as spread useful content.
  By AllisonNazarian | Boca Raton, FL September 23, 2008 09:24:48 am:
I think this post does a great job of outlining all of the challenges of writing, maintaining and promoting a blog the right (and successful) way.

As a copywriter with a specialty in blog writing/ghostwriting, I couldn't agree more with many of your points. All too many people expect their blogs to be a "quick fix" -- write one or two posts and Voila! Instant Success. It just doesn't happen that way. And you can have the most beautiful-looking blog with all the widgets, tools and bells and whistles available but if you don't have content -- relevant, updated, never-ending content - -then you may as well not have a blog. People don't always like to hear that, but it's true.

With the right content, the right expectations/attitude and a good product/service to begin with, blogs and bloggers can enjoy attention and success that they may not have had access to in pre-blog days of the past.

Great, honest advice!

Allison Nazarian
www.GetItInWriting.biz
www.CopywritingforVAs.com
www.AllisonNazarian.com
  By ryanmoede | Falls Church, VA September 23, 2008 09:28:13 am:
Great post - it's this kind of honest upfront assessment that clients need to hear before diving into what too often becomes a blogging disaster.
  By BBPR | SAN DIEGO, CA September 23, 2008 12:56:19 pm:
GREAT piece!

Because of the work I do (many clients are in youth culture, green or action sports), I've been working with online media for some time. Some of my clients have blogs, some don't, and this article sums up the cons very succinctly.

A blog isn't going to just generate new business or leads on it's own. Similar to other marketing initiatives, it takes time and resources to do it right.

This holds true for Twitter, Facebook, social bookmarking, etc.

-bb
www.bbpublicrelations.com
www.bbpr.wordpress.com
  By devoraipg | Los Angeles, CA September 23, 2008 02:22:15 pm:
Thanks for the article; I agree blogging requires time and patience and is not worthwhile if a company doesn't devote appropriate resources to the endeavor. That said, if the CEO and others on staff actually enjoy writing and a content editor is hired to lead the blog, it can work very well. Beyond that, the question I ask of anyone seeking to start a corporate blog is, how willing are you to talk about interesting things and give real insight? At our Future or Media blog (http://blog.ipglab.com), I am constantly encouraging our team to share indepth and original opinions and try to solicit executives to write as well.
  By andredps | sao paulo September 23, 2008 04:14:32 pm:
Good job, B.L.

Let me add a 11th: sooner or later somebody will have to create a "10 reazons..." post.

And, as we all know, anybody can list 10 reasons for anything.

Pro or against... but the last one is always easier.
  By scottmonty | Dearborn, MI September 23, 2008 06:49:33 pm:
Wait - this isn't a list of reasons not to blog; more accurately, this is a list of challenges they'll face as they start a blog. As marketers & communicators, if we were to give up every time a challenge presented itself, we'd never get anything done!

I like how you've summarized these points that address some huge assumptions out there. For someone (like yourself, for example), who makes it look easy, there's a number of different things to consider as you enter the blogging world. It's taken me a while to build a decent following over on www.scottmonty.com, but it's been worth the effort.
  By stephenpbyrne | Australia September 23, 2008 06:59:02 pm:
I wonder how many corporate marketing and PR agencies are going to read this and take notice. From BL's standpoint they don't seem to be getting a lot of good advice. Yesterday I met with a global digital agency who told me their clients still don't have much idea about analytics, still don't do any analysis if they are running any type of traffic and usage collection and just find the plethora of information available overwhelming. I've blogging on branding and marketing for nearly four years and have built a readership of nearly 40000. It's a hard slog and you do need to be a good writer and editor. I don't agree you need a designer to make it look good though it doesn't hurt. There are plenty of good blogs out there that have been done on the smell of an oily rag. Hopefully BL's comments and those of other commentators will continue to trickle down to the client level and not just reside here. We all know it's true.

Stephen Byrne
DIFFUSION
www.diffusionblog.blogspot.com
  By BL | NEW YORK, NY September 23, 2008 07:02:48 pm:
Thanks for all these comments, with much good advice.

Scott - Thanks for the nice compliment about What's Next Blog, http://whatsnextblog.com making it look easy. It's not. :>)

my post absolutely IS a list of challenges, and it also frequently tongue in cheek.

Blogging regularly and successfully to a large international audience is challenging and time-consuming, but also one of the most rewarding things I've ever done.

The only real reason one can keep blogging day after day and year after year is love: of writing, reading, researching, interacting with people who agree and disagree with you.

Blogging has created great opportunity for me, brought me extraordinary clients and wonderful friends. But make no mistake, like anyone else with 120,000 unique visits a week, I work hard at it.
  By BL | NEW YORK, NY September 23, 2008 07:29:59 pm:
"...don't you think the community at large would be better served by encouraging everyone to blog - but to do so correctly - as opposed to making blogging out to be a $100,000 per year plus corporate endeavor fraught with pitfalls and problems for already busy executives?"

Nicholas - nope. I don't think everyone should be encouraged to blog - only those who truly have something to say that other people want to read. That's not everyone - not by a mile!

As for the $100K - a figure I didn't name, BTW - a blog that represents a major corporation needs to share the company's graphic identity, and professional design and programming is *not* free.

But more important, and more often overlooked, is the fact that companies need to drive traffic to their blogs. That takes more than a link from the home page. And, frankly, $100K isn't a huge ad budget in the Fortune 10,000.
  By BL | NEW YORK, NY September 23, 2008 07:34:37 pm:
Jim Cahill has a great slide presentation on the perils and opportunities of blogging. Take a look. He nails it! http://tinyurl.com/4noehn
  By EmerLawn | New York, NY September 24, 2008 03:52:03 am:
Hi there,

Thanks for the post. As someone who's recently become highly active in our company blog (http://www.interactivereturn.com/blog), your "10 Reasons" caught my eye, and had me prepared to defend myself. But it turns out the points you outlined are very important considerations...the point being that Blogging is not for everyone. I agree, there are blogs out there that do not or will never have an active following, and if they are investing a lot of time, then it may be a waste.

However, I think this should be called "10 Considerations before Creating a Blog", because the advantages of Blogging for certain companies are infinite, as you yourself mentioned that you've gotten a lot of clients, contacts, and traffic out of it.

So I agree...to an extent. I would however debate the "not cheap" factor, because with the free software that is available to create your blog (i.e. Word Press), all you need is a lil dedication. Monetarily...I feel its cost effective.

Some jumbled thoughts there, but thanks again for the post!

Emer Lawn, Online Marketing Executive, Interactive Return
  By xsnor | trenton, NJ September 25, 2008 03:49:42 am:
I disagree with point 9 where you can edit a good template quite easily.
If your company is into any unethical practices do not blog.This will open a can of worms.
Promotion a company blog(a tainted company) on another site would just cause people to post link to reviews and facts which show the true light of the company.
  By DaveAllen | Portland, OR September 26, 2008 12:16:49 pm:
Social Media is in danger of being over-hyped yet it has a very useful function. The only danger in having a company blog is when the company doesn't hire an employee who is dedicated to running it. Effective blogging takes skill but there is absolutely no reason why a company should not all of the useful tools that are available today.
I covered the same issues back in July...on Nemo's company blog - Why Does Corporate Social Networking Fail?
http://www.social-cache.com/2008/07/why-does-corporate-social-networking-fail



Stay on top of the news and stay ahead of the game—sign up for e-mail newsletters now!



Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News