November 25, 2009
Login | Register Now

Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News


More from Ad Age:
Creativity
Ad Age China
Bookstore
Jobs
Ad Age On Campus
Sign up for E-mail Newsletters

Garfield's Ad Review

Stay on top of the news, sign up for our free newsletters


Taking Cadillac from Stodgy to Sexy: Kate Walsh

Grey's Anatomy Star Brings Erotic Allure to a Tired Brand

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Submit to Digg Add to Google Share on StumbleUpon Submit to LinkedIn Add to Newsvine Bookmark on Del.icio.us Submit to Reddit

Cadillac ... sexy?

That should be a laugh line. For most of the past 40 years, Cadillac has more or less been synonymous with white-belted retirees driving at 39 mph to get their prostates checked. By the 1970s, the once-proud luxury brand, the erstwhile mark of wealth and achievement, had devolved into a sofa on wheels.
Title: Turn You On
Marketer: Cadillac
image
Agency: Modernista, Boston
Image
Grey's Anatomy star Kate Walsh pumps some erotic excitement into Cadillace advertising. | ALSO: Comment on this review in the 'Your Opinion' box below.


Then it became a Chevy with fancy trim. Then it became a non-factor in the luxury car market, holding cachet only for extremely aggressive Mary Kay distributors and the near dead.

But then GM set about designing a stylish car worthy of the already impressive Northstar engine and in 2003 introduced a boldly faceted CTS, a midsize sedan trapped in a stealth fighter's body. It turned heads appropriately, showed up in "Matrix Reloaded" and benefited from a fair amount of buzz.

It did not, however, turn the brand around.

This had something to do with Leo Burnett's unexceptional advertising and something to do with accrued bad will. Since then, in classic GM fashion, the glacial product cycle killed off whatever buzz momentum Cadillac briefly enjoyed and, as the 2008 model year commences, it's back at square one.

But wait. The CTS has been thoroughly redesigned. It's a gorgeous little rocket that could have exactly the halo effect GM is looking for, provided anybody ever notices the introduction. And, count on one thing: They will. New TV spots from Modernista, Boston, are eye-catching, ear-catching, informative, cerebral and -- dare we say? -- pretty freakin' sexy.

This owes partly to the celebrity talent -- notably Kate Walsh from "Grey's Anatomy." We want her to have our children. No, really. We have three children, and she can have all of them if she'll just read copy for us -- any copy: cat food, industrial boilers, HeadOn, anything -- the way she reads her Cadillac lines:

"In today's luxury game, the question isn't whether or not your car has available features like a 40-gig hard drive. It isn't about sun roofs or Sapelli wood accents, popup nav screens or any of that. No, the real question is: When you turn your car on, does it return the favor?" The italics are mine, because the printed word fails here. You need to hear her voice. Walsh sounds a little bored, her words slightly slurred, as if she were two pomegranate martinis into the evening but with her wits totally about her.

For instance, though she first dismisses the significance of luxury-car features per se, she still manages to list the highlights. And they're duly registered -- right up to where she mentions erotic stimulation and floors the gas pedal in her high-heeled sandal.

Sure enough, suddenly the GPS system doesn't seem to matter. And prostate patients everywhere feel hope. (And so will women, who are sure to see this brazen foxiness as empowering -- and maybe more than that. Unless we are grossly misinterpreting her last line, this sounds like an ad for a $40,000 vibrator.)

Another spot, featuring Martin Henderson from "Smokin' Aces," is one of two that dares BMW and Lexus prospects to get out of lockstep: "You can practice risk avoidance. You can aspire to blend in quietly. You can live in, drive and wear social camouflage. And you can believe in the philosophy that the nail that sticks out gets hammered down. Or you can be the hammer."

Iconoclasm, of course, is often the last refuge of a marginal brand. But this is a 300-horsepower variant, not merely challenging conformists but enticing them and playing to their vanity. It doesn't hurt, either, that the car looks just plain ... sexy.
22 Comments
Subscribe to comments on: Taking Cadillac from Stodgy to Sexy: Kate Walsh
  By zdenekkratky | Stamford, CT October 1, 2007 09:24:06 am:
The real question is 'who is cadillac targetting?' Agree that the spot's different, then the traditional 0-60 in x seconds thanks to the y horsepower engine; but really it's still too many images 'speeding' by too quickly - all features, a little hyperbole (not much the way it's shot, frankly) and no real impact. So, what is the car good at? 'Driving excitement'? Oh, no, that's BMW. Safety - Volvo. Quality and luxury - Lexus. So I guess it's good at 'exciting' slightly sedated, women in their forties. Can't wait to see the sales numbers.
  By KRIS | PITTSBURGH, PA October 1, 2007 10:23:47 am:
maybe the kate walsh ad could be considered sexy if it wasn't just so darned familiar. it was considerably so when it appeared for sylvania in the 1997 ca advertising annual, 'when you turn on the bedroom light, does it return the favor?' -- perhaps because the light bulb is a much more unexpected place for a turn-on than an automaker struggling to be relevant.
  By Dustin | Tulsa, OK October 1, 2007 12:43:10 pm:
I don't know. New copy in the same tired beauty shots? I don't think the few who don't use the mute button will be terribly impressed.

It just seems like Modernista is peddling Viagra-creative to a tired, old brand.

Caddie may be more to blame than the agency.
  By danspocket | Fairfield, OH October 1, 2007 01:28:58 pm:
When I saw this ad the first time I literally sat up in my seat, turned to my wife, and asked, "Did you hear that copy!?" Given, I'm an AD for a packaging firm, but still...the copy, the imagery, the question, followed by that music! WOW! For the record, though, this 31 year old guy already had a McCrush on McSexy from her show. Still... the ad works for me.
  By Bob | Boston, MA October 1, 2007 02:18:25 pm:
//When you turn your car on, does it return the favor?"//

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but isn't that the identical line Mullen used to sell lighbulbs a few years back? It was in CA and One Show.
  By Forrest | Moraga, CA October 1, 2007 06:48:23 pm:
If you're an (ahem) devoted fan of Ms. Walsh, this ad probably does it for you. Otherwise, I was more interested by the cinematography and music than the car (or Ms. Walsh).
  By Allenye | Mechanicsville, VA October 2, 2007 04:04:55 pm:
The old man with prostate problems story is funny, but to me Cadillac is a brand that's always been associated with rappers trying to trick them out. Im suprised their sales were dwindling with the MTV show "Cribs" showing 8 of them in every episode... or am I?
  By Morgan | Rolla, MO October 2, 2007 11:38:31 pm:
I agree with the "rapper" comment. Every time I see see an Escalade on the streets of our sleepy little mid-western town I wonder if the driver knows what an icon the vehicle is in the world of the gangsta?


Maybe I'm too old or just too out of touch...but every time I see sex being use to sell a product, I ask myself why?


Rolla, Missouri

  By Brian | St. Louis, MO October 3, 2007 10:39:27 am:
I don't know Michael Hart, but if I were him I'd be going through the roof right now. He's the CW credited with the "... return the favor" line for Sylvania. I realize that ideas/lines have some overlap over the years, but as creatives we are responsible for remembering the great ideas and not repeating them. The Sylvania campaign was a great one. And the fact that both Mullen and Modernista are both in Massachusettes makes it even more suspect. Anybody have any insight here?

Brian. St. Louis, MO
  By browncatfan | Allendale, MI October 3, 2007 12:07:52 pm:
Juvenile masquerading as "sexy." After years of blaming men for the phallic/car connection, suddenly we're supposed to think it's cool when it is suggested as a woman's phallic symbol?

High-heeled sandal indeed. What, just couldn't risk the CU of her fondling the shift column? Old, embarrassing idea--right for the times if the times were the 60s.
  By Mantion | Dallas, TX October 29, 2007 08:00:32 am:
What a retarded idea. It would be funny if she was selling washing machines for Maytag. She could throw a brick in it to demonstrate its dependably then sit on it set it for spin cycle and say "when you turn your washing machine on, does it return the favor".

But you know what I am not dumb enough to buy a Caddicrap, so clearly I am not the intended demographics.
  By Josh | Portland, ME November 13, 2007 09:45:55 am:
I think the asthetics of the spot are great. However, I, as others, have a problem with the payoff line. Regarless if it has been "repurposed," (ahem) from a Mullen campaign or not, to me the line just doesn't work. Forgive me for being logical, but you turn on a computer, a phone, a TV... perhaps even a woman. But does one really "turn on" a car? Even with push button ignitions and the like, I believe people still START their cars. Too forced. Josh in Portland, ME
  By drvrseat | manheim, PA December 16, 2007 10:25:13 pm:
Being an Import automobile dealer I don't usually see Cadillac as a threat. Having said that, I have watched them consistently improve their product, as well as market it. Reading the comments to date I have to wonder if you folks are still alive. Both my 24 year old son & 54 year old wife agree with me, this is one sexy commercial. If I am in the market for a new car, I would consisder visiting Cadillac.
  By lennA | Westland, MI December 26, 2007 07:17:45 pm:
I have to agree with Mark Kreider. I wonder if the rest of you have a pulse. I know that those of us in advertising and marketing tend to be jaded, but the comments I see here, aside from Mark Kreider's, were best described on a car detailing forum - automotive snobbery. If it comes from a Detroit automaker, it gets slammed. So Sylvania used the tag line first. Big damn deal. Sorry critics, but Kate Walsh makes it work. Leo Burnett's Led Zeppelin targeted the right segment, but missed. Modernista hit the target dead on. Everyone in the auto industry, including import dealers like Mark Kreider, talk about the Kate Walsh spot. Then they talk about the CTS. The anti-Detroit snobs may not take he Cadillac CTS (and the 2008 STS) seriously, but the competition has noticed.
  By fred001 | Syracuse, NY January 14, 2008 11:31:57 am:
I agree that the ad is verrrrrry sexy and catches one's attention, even if simply by the novelty of a sexy Caddy ad.


But I often wonder if marketers imagine their base market is populated by blind idiots.


First, there was that ghastly TV ad with the newly promoted woman walking through the office as the men cowered and even (symbolically) wet themselves in her presence; now this ad that cements the Caddy-wants-women message. Do they really imagine that they can insult, denigrate, belittle and forget men so obtusely and the male viewing audience won't notice? If the majority of their market is middle-aged men with prostate problems, do they really imagine that this is any way to keep that market? More likely is that for every young female exec who gets excited by the prospect of being turned on by her Caddy, there is a middle-aged man thinking "Oh, the new Caddies are chick cars, guess I won't be buying one of them next time around...". I know I and my prostate did.

  By Kalie | Hillsborough, NJ February 26, 2008 05:51:07 pm:
I first wanted to comment on Kate Walsh's voice in this ad because I thought that it could have been so much stronger, especially for the way in which she was trying to sell the car. Her voice seemed too dull to convince me that I need this Cadillac. Aside from her un-energetic voice she did infact add sex appeal to the commercial with her image, which seems to be the route that many advertisements are taking these days. Especially since she is a mature, well known, beautiful actress...younger woman aspire to be her, woman her age want to be like her, and men are attracted to her. Although I do think that the target audience for this Cadillac Ad is women who desire to be powerful and sexy in their own Cadillac. According to the Rank's model I think this commercial falls a little short in following all five seps in order to convince the targeted audience that they need this product. The image and use of celebrity is all there, but Walsh's unvaried, unexpressive voice causes the advertisement to fall a little flat. Maybe she was just trying too hard to make her voice contain sex appeal, but in my opinion it caused the ad to be unconvincing.
  By Kalie | Hillsborough, NJ February 26, 2008 06:07:25 pm:
I would like to first comment on Kate Walsh's voice in this advertisement. In my opinion her voice is dull and un-energetic, and causes the advertisement to fall flat. The ad does utilize image and celebrity. This Cadillac Ad seems to be targeting an audience of women who desire to be powerful and sexy while driving a Cadillac, so they have pretty much diverted from any men really longing to have this car. According to the Rank's model, this advertisement falls a little short. Using a mature, talented, beautiful celebrity like Walsh drags in the girls and women who aspire to be like her but fails to appeal to a broad audience. Additionally, the use of sex appeal in relation to the product is convicing, but Walsh's unvaried and unexpressive voice does little to accompany the commercial and convince me that I need this car.
  By byelichl | Lawrenceville, NJ February 26, 2008 07:50:09 pm:
I love Kate Walsh. I think she has the "bad girl" look that fit perfect for the commercial. One thing that surprised me though was her boring voice! When I first clicked on the video I thought it was going to be upbeat. Her voice was low and not entertaining at all. When she was talking about the features I didn't even listen. Everyone knows she has a sexy voice but I didn't feel any emotion from her. I did like the colors and graphics, and it did make me think, "wow that is a hot car!"
  By rlynn24 | Lawrenceville, NJ February 27, 2008 01:19:50 am:
I understand the argument that Kate Walsh's voice is boring during this commercial, but I think it was done on purpose. I think her intentions were to subtly list the features, but then to present the line, "Does it return the favor?" with much more passion. In my opinion she did come off as sexy, and the visual graphics made up for the boring tone of her voice while she spoke about the car's features.
  By angelat328 | Lawrenceville, NJ February 27, 2008 08:50:50 am:
Well, personally I did not see a problem with the way she presented the commercial at all. I thought it was very sexy, which is obviously the goal of the advertisement. As far as her voice goes, I did not find that to be a problem either. Yes her words were a little slurred but I recall hearing her pronunciate very well which overrides the slurring.
  By Benito | Denver, NM March 2, 2008 12:15:00 pm:
I've searched for the cup holder ad and can't find it, but that was beyond sexy -- it was downright nasty in a subtle way. Hasn't anyone picked up on the slurred beginning "cuckolder" for "cup holder" and the clarification at the end, while maintaing the theme by indicating a new type of woman. This is all in sync with the latest craze in men's sex, of course.
  By PitStop1938 | Modesto, CA October 28, 2008 02:02:35 am:
Wonder what a CTS would Sound like with Flowmasters and Miss Kate's heavy right foot ... Understand she did some on-track runs at the Bondurant School for High Performance Driving in Arizona.
:

Note: Comments submitted to AdAge.com are posted automatically and will include the user name with which you registered. Ad Age reserves the right to delete comments that are insulting or personal in nature. Comments may be used in the print edition at editorial discretion. Comments are restricted to 500 words or less.




Stay on top of the news and stay ahead of the game—sign up for e-mail newsletters now!



Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News