November 23, 2009
Login | Register Now

Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News


More from Ad Age:
Creativity
Ad Age China
Bookstore
Jobs
Ad Age On Campus
Sign up for E-mail Newsletters

Stay on top of the news, sign up for our free newsletters


Comcast Must Die: Chapter 4

My Phones Don't Work, and Theirs Don't Either

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Submit to Digg Add to Google Share on StumbleUpon Submit to LinkedIn Add to Newsvine Bookmark on Del.icio.us Submit to Reddit

Part 1 / Part 2 / Part 3 / Part 4

Was traveling for the past few days, as one does in September, in Bulgaria. It was nice. The telephones worked.

No such luck at home, where my wife has been haunted by the Ghost of Comcast.

As you may have read, we were the victims of an incomplete, haphazard and faulty installation of phone-cable-broadband service, and then we were victims of an indifferent, dishonest and hostile "customer service" process. At one point, with my blood pressure spiking and an episode of tachycardia, I feared for my health.

I don't wish to die of Comcast.

But because I blogged about this, and because I am a major, major multimediocrity, Comcast executives fell all over themselves issuing press releases, having vice presidents call my home, sending supervisors to fix what was broken and basically giving me all the attention you'd never receive, because you can do them no harm. While I was gone, my wife reports, she was practically harrassed by phone by Qualmcastic employees looking after our wellbeing.

But the phones still don't work. Whenever we hang up on a call, a few seconds later the phone rings again -- with the connection that was never closed. Our house sounds like the back set of a telethon.

But today I got yet another call from Qualmcast. It was a young woman named Michelle doing what seemed to be a random customer-satisfaction survey on our (nightmare) "Comcast Triple Play" installation.

"On a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being best best how would you rate your service?" she asked.

"Zero," I said. There was a prolonged pause.

"May I ask what the problem was?" she continued, and I explained. She apologized and offered to connect me to someone who could help. Why not? I was curious if the routine follow-up would yield any results. "You will be on hold," she explained, "and it will be silent on the line for a moment."

"OK," I said. "Thank you."

What followed was 20 seconds of silence. Then, a rapid busy signal. Qualmcast, apparently for reasons no more sinister than its utter incompetence, had hung up on me.
22 Comments
Subscribe to comments on: Comcast Must Die: Chapter 4
  By ANAND | BOSTON, MA September 19, 2007 06:25:00 pm:
honestly Bob, quit whining.

A.
  By cvt906 | upper marlboro, MD September 19, 2007 07:12:56 pm:
bob I feel your pain I am having that same problem. I cant use the internet if I cant use my phone and they want you to sign a 2 year contract for what. I told the rep yesterday that I was going to cancel my service. All they could tell me is that it must be a weak signal. Then why would they advertise a servise in an area where no one can use it. Comcast is just ripping people off. So Anand from Boston you need to keep your comments to yourself if youd dont understand what customer service is. cheree , maryland
  By Richard | Boston, MA September 20, 2007 12:25:58 am:
I'm with Anand from Boston, Comcast sucks, but that's customer service these days. Besides, you get what you pay for when you buy a service that claims its COMCASTIC.
  By bjkeefe | Rochester, NY September 20, 2007 03:26:01 am:
While you're on the jihad, Bob, you might also look into Comcast cutting off customers' Internet access for "excessive downloading."


I don't use Comcast, but I keep seeing stories about people being shut down. The problem is, the people have signed up for what is advertised as "unlimited access." It gets worse: when they try to straighten out the problem by asking "how much is excessive?," Comcast refuses to state a limit.


If you want to add this to your list of complaints in which I hope will turn into a book, or at least, an OTM rant, Googling "comcast download limits" should give you a place to start.

  By RAMON | CHICAGO, IL September 20, 2007 08:34:59 am:
Called Comcast and signed up for triple play(internet,cable,phone) First guy went up to the attic and came down said it was too hot and left.
Second guy walked in, ripped stuff out of walls and said he really did not know what he was doing and quit on the spot
Third guy hooked everything up but nothing worked
Fourth guy came in and said that everything was on backwards and fixed it all
Trying to explain problems to customer service through all of this was impossible. It's probably easier to get things done in Iraq than trying to get this company to listen
  By Jim | Buffalo Grove, IL September 20, 2007 09:04:57 am:
I've had Comcast out to our house after upgrading to Digital Voice Service at least 10x. Each service rep checks the modem, the outside box and puts blame on the previous work done. Meanwhile when we're on the phone and someone else calls, both lines get disconnected immediately. And then there is having to reset the modem to restore phone service, virtually every week. Not a major thing unless we are away from home and call in for our messages in which case, nothing works. As for the high speed computer Internet service, everytime I've worked from home it, too, has gone out several times over the day. Comcast just tells us there seems to be a drop in power from the outside box to the inside of the house but there is nothing they can do. I guess I'll just get to spend another 45-minutes on hold the next time the problems escalate. -- Jim Norman, Buffalo Grove, IL
  By Sue | Cape Coral, FL September 20, 2007 09:05:00 am:
Where do I start? I ordered internet which took them weeks to make work. Then I ordered the digital phone - as soon as they installed, my intenet stopped working. They refused to get the installation guys back to correct the job - they said they didn't know how to get a hold of them. During my HOURS of phone conversations with customer service from Canada to who-knows where they told my I never had internet - only cable and phone! (I never had cable TV). It took days and HOURS of phone calls to finally get a service guy back out to fix the problem. Even the service guy had to WAIT for HOURS on the phone too. Go figure. THEN they overcharged me two months in a row for service. Why pay retail when you can pay more? I spent HOURS more trying to straighten out the billing. Then the customer service people told since they weren't in my region they couldn't fix the billing problems - only my region had authorization to do that. THEN WHY WAS I ROUTED TO TIM-BUCK-TOO?

This is just the short version - and does not include ALL the painful details.

Sue - Cape Coral Florida
  By Susanna | Nashville, TN September 20, 2007 09:13:06 am:
I, too, have had huge frustrations with Comcast. Too many incidents to count, but I did actually blog about one of the incidents, where I was basically ON HOLD FOR THREE HOURS waiting for someone from Customer Service. The story is pretty hilarious - if you want to read about it, visit http://scuuster.wordpress.com/2007/06/11/comcast/
-Susanna Custer, Nashville, TN
  By Bo Pittman | Charlotte, NC September 20, 2007 09:23:36 am:
As bad as it can be sometimes, Thank God for Time Warner (that should show the state of things for Internet connectivity).
  By gavsky | London September 20, 2007 09:46:57 am:
I'm not American, but I say: Vote Bob for President!

This whole tragic state of affairs is taking on Shakespearean proportions. It ressembles my own tear-stained (OK, I exaggerate slightly on that last point) attempt to get the UK's desservedly much-maligned telecoms + broadband provider , TalkTalk, to properly setup their euivalent broadband/telephone service and maybe even provide a degree of customer support worthy of the name. It took months of phone calls. But to this day, they never ever EVER responded to any of my emails pleading for help.

Gavin, UK
  By sptrapani | Savannah, GA September 20, 2007 10:49:14 am:
When do the DirecTV "comcastia syndrom" spots come out? ;-)
  By Bill | Chicago, IL September 20, 2007 10:57:01 am:
Comcast is the worst. I have had them out more times than I can count. Each rube blames the other rube. My question is what can we do since they are a licensed entity to stop the madness.
  By David | Mt. Kisco, NY September 20, 2007 11:26:04 am:
I think a sitcom could be developed out of all this... community of
of young folks having to spend all their free time struggling with Comcast. Each week with a different frustrating scenario.

David, Mount Kisco, NY
  By nicole180 | New York, NY September 20, 2007 11:54:09 am:
I absolutely love this series. As an inhabitant of NJ, we are given no alternative but Comcast. The best is when you call to report a problem and they get angry at you for NOT accepting their Triple Threat Deal. Then they come over, barely speak English, and leave a mess for you to clean up. Five days later, you are back on the phone with the same problem. Please keep this series going!
  By Oliver | New York, NY September 20, 2007 12:04:03 pm:
Bob - can you gives us a good faith disclosure that you are not receiving compensation or inducements from another provider of video & broadband services?
  By mmartinatlanta | Atlanta, GA September 20, 2007 12:26:40 pm:
I have had Comcrapstic high speed internet for a year and a half since they are the only provider available to me. Every time it rains my service goes down. I have called them 8 times and each time I get a different excuse but the best was when they told me if I walked around my neighborhood and got the names and account numbers of 7 other neighbors that were also having trouble, only then would they replace the lines. One service tech actually said to me "just consider yourself lucky you don't have our cable, it's even worse". The mere mention of the word Comcast sets people off and everyone has a horror story. Why do our city officials who handle contracts allow this to continue?

Mike Martin, Dunwoody GA
Bob, great that you visited my country and the phone connection was running smoothly. But do not think we do not have problems with the phones and Internet connection and having to fight a former monopoly with still-in-the-communist-mentality of caveat emptor administration which is hopefully replaced by young and professional customer service representatives. The question is what will happen if you just unplugg the phone and leave it quiet for a while, take a walk, do some sports, go outside and realize that actually they are doing you a favour-taking off the pressure of our modern 24/7 availability. There are still places in Bulgaria where we do not have cell phone coverage and when I happen in such a place I start to appreciate it. Technology and connection to the world is important, but there are more important things like several million people in Africa having no telephone in their homes or no home at all. Why not write about this inconvenient truth. Meri, Sofia, Bulgaria
  By Al | Ventura, CA September 20, 2007 03:29:30 pm:
And then there is entirely another vista where Comcast can ruin your life; it is the Comcast Blacklist Nightmare (Google that for some fun reading).

We are a franchise company and communicate via e-mail with a broad cross section of potentially interested franchise prospects. Twice our company has been blacklisted by Comcast though we only respond to inquiries and send no spam of any type and our servers are well protected and have all of the correct protocols. It can take hours to find someone at Comcast who will even acknowledge such a list exists and many more hours and in one case almost three months to get off the blacklist and be allowed to communicate with Comcast customers.

So once those Comcast customers finally do get their e-mail up and running, there is an ongoing slice of the world that can't communicate with them...
  By dmurphy7 | Rochester Hills, U. September 20, 2007 04:42:17 pm:
fortunately, WOW becam available in our area about 6 years ago. They are great. When I die my tombstone will say: Dennis Murphy "I hate Comcast".
  By GREG | NEW YORK, NY September 20, 2007 07:56:27 pm:
I have had similar problems with Time Warner. I do not have an option of using another service provider in my area. A company that essentially has a monopoly in an area needs to fix their problems. Yet, they do not. Non-sense. I feel you Bob.
  By Christopher | San Jose, CA September 20, 2007 08:33:23 pm:
I was lucky. Having enough with AT&T Internet, I decided to switch to Comcast. I tried twice to reach a sales representative but both times I was on hold for ~30 minutes and then hung up. Obviously, after the second try I decided that if their sales people could not answer the phone within thirty minutes to sign up a new customer, it must be hell for existing customers to get anyone on the phone.
  By ROGER | BOONE, NC September 21, 2007 12:20:56 pm:
I think you're doing yourself a "major" disservice here, Bob; at the very least, you are a major, major, major multimediocrity... . Very interesting read, but very sorry for your frustrations. I hope the problems go away -- and that they're not catchy.... Cheers! - RD



Stay on top of the news and stay ahead of the game—sign up for e-mail newsletters now!



Advertising Age: Your Online Source for Marketing and Media News