Brad Paisley and Carrie Underwood host last week's Country Music Awards.
Credit:
Provided by Donn Jones
Country music has a perception problem. Conventional wisdom is
that it's an advertising backwater of low-income Luddites from C
and D counties. Perhaps country crooner David Allan Coe put it best
when he sang that the perfect country and western song has lyrics
about "mama, trains, trucks, prison or getting drunk."
Those are the stereotypes that the Country Music Association was
out to quash last week with a cowboy boot camp for advertisers that
drew marketers from companies you might expect would be drawn to
the genre—Cabela's, Mack Trucks, Anheuser-Busch's Natural
Light and Pilot Flying J—but also some outliers like Aflac,
Comcast, U.S. Bank, Unilever
and the U.S. Olympic Committee.
"There will be a lot of surprises when you see the numbers,"
Damon Whiteside, CMO at the CMA, told the 32 attendees.
Karen Stump, senior director of market research, set out to
knock down what she called "outdated" notions of country. Among the
stats she delivered about who consumes country music: They comprise
more than 46 percent of U.S. adults, 40 percent of boomers, 39
percent of millennials and 40 percent of Gen Xers. The average
household income of country listeners is $81,800, versus $78,800
for the general population, she says.
But the association's biggest pitch might just be this: Country
stars are brand-friendly and they have dedicated fan bases.
"I get it. Everybody wants Katy Perry. In country the numbers
are lower, but the engagement is higher," says Cameo Carlson,
president of artist development group mTheory.
Damon Whiteside, CMO of the CMA, addresses the Brand Marketing Summit held at the Country Music Hall of Fame.
Brad Paisley even went off script during last year's Country
Music Association Awards show to sing "Are you here to sell
insurance?" to the tune of the Nationwide jingle, addressing the
insurer's other spokesman at the event, Peyton Manning. That was
unpaid. "Trust me, we would have tried to monetize that," says
Emily Evans, senior director of strategic partnerships at the
CMA.
Several attendees at the boot camp said they were drawn to the
genre's comparative cost-effectiveness. Tanvi Sikand, senior
marketing manager for brand and media partnerships at
Balsam Hill, a maker of artificial Christmas trees, advertised
on the "CMA Country Christmas" show last year—and got her
trees onstage as set decoration.
"I was nervous watching the show because it was a big chunk of
our budget," she says. But Balsam Hill's website visits climbed
beyond her expectations during the airing, she says. She is
returning this year as a sponsor.
Tara Dowling, associate director of strategy at Spark Foundry,
says she came to explore allying a client with music as a potential
differentiator in a high-spending category. Another person in
attendance said that a buy on the CMAs is a relative bargain
compared with shows like the Grammys.
According to an Ad Age analysis, the average cost for the 2016
CMA Awards show was $250,000 per 30-second spot, compared with
$985,000 in the 2017 Grammys. Last week's CMA Awards delivered a
3.2 rating in viewers age 18 to 49, up 10 percent from last year
when it was facing Game 7 of the World Series, and drew 14.3
million total viewers, up 14 percent, according to Nielsen. By
comparison, the Grammys brought in a 7.8 rating in adults 18 to 49
and 26.1 million viewers in total.
In an industry where "authenticity" is a huge buzzword, the CMA
claims it delivers in abundance. "Rihanna probably doesn't drive a
Chevy, but country music stars do," says Shari Lewin, a partner at
WME handling commercial endorsements.
They also drive Mack Trucks—or at least have relatives who
work on them. Mack tapped singer-songwriter Steve Moakler to pen
the song "Born Ready" for a dealer event to unveil a new truck.
Moakler says he was drawn to the project because his granddad once
was a truck mechanic. He ended up creating a stirring anthem to the
workingman who spends most of his time on the road to make life
better for his family. The marketing team "came to my release show"
for a chemistry meeting, says Moakler, and they got so fired up
that "we shut that bar down."
It was a risk for Mack, however, because it had little to no
input in the song. "I downplayed it in the boardroom because I had
heard some of these deals don't go so well, so if that happened I
was going to bury it," says John Walsh, Mack's VP of marketing.
"Then crap, we have this fantastic song." Mack produced a video for
it that clocked more than 50,000 views on YouTube in its first two
months, and is expanding its relationship with Moakler.
Liz Daney, exec VP and chief media offer at Fitzco in Atlanta,
attended the summit on behalf of a financial client that normally
sponsors sports. "There has been some tarnish on sports these
days," she says. "I'm looking for something a bit more
positive."
Daney says she was taken aback by "the openness of the CMA and
talent agencies to explore opportunities across budget levels." The
event, she says, helped break down stereotypes, citing a performer
the CMA brought in to entertain the group—a country beatboxer
named Walker Hayes.
"Diversity is happening in country music," she says. "It is not
this C and D county 50-year-old white guy listening. The genre has
so many nuances to it, and a breadth of different artists."
Judann Pollack (Judy) is executive editor of Ad Age. She joined Ad Age in 1985 as editorial assistant, along the way fielding pretty much every position on the masthead, including reporter, Chicago bureau chief, New York bureau chief, features editor, executive editor and managing editor-international.