What to Buy Your Creative Friends this Holiday Season

By Published on .

Walmart Stores this holiday season launched an app that takes the guesswork out of gift-giving -- just in time for Christmas. The app, Shopycat, scours Facebook profiles, looking at interests, comments, updates and likes to pick the perfect gift. Online craft-emporium Etsy also has a Gift Ideas app, which offers up gift ideas of a more handmade variety.

Creatives can be hard to shop for, so we asked these apps to recommend some gifts for some of the industry's creative talents. Check out the recommendations -- and the reactions -- below and read about Shopycat in Behind the Work.

Robert Lund, McCann Worldgroup
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

Katy Perry: A Life of Fireworks paperback

Inception DVD, Blu-Ray, Widescreen


"I've seen Inception and I don't really like Katy Perry. I guess that app can tell people when it's time to look over what [Facebook] pages you like."

Jeremy Miller, TBWA
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

Game of Thrones Sword Letter Opener, $19.99

New York Yankees Framed Collage, 149.99

Advertising Age: The Principles of Advertising, $32.22


On the letter opener: "How would I get through airport security? It feels like I would see that in Sky Mall along with Gandalf's Staff letter opener, Harry Potters wand, and my precious ring

PJ Pereira, Pereira & O'Dell
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

The Social Network, Blu-Ray, Widescreen $19.96

Lesson Booster: Internet Bullies Program with CD-Rom $44.96


Hmmm you would be giving me a gift a few years before I need it, cause my son is still in pre-school. But I would definitely keep it for later. I mean, i don't know if DVDs will still exist by the time he's ready but I'd keep it anyway. Thanks :-)

Fernanda Romano, EuroRSCG
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

Star Wars Jedi & Sith Bath Robes $89.99

The Essential New York Times Cookbook $20.85


Hopefully she wears the robes.

Jose Molla, CCO, La Comunidad
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

George Foreman Quesadilla Maker

The Official Chuck Norris Fact Book

The Picture of Dorian Gray

Olive Garden $25 Gift Card

Personalized Keepsake Box


I'm one of those lucky guys who's never lost a friend over a woman or a debt. But this list will probably do it.

Let's see. I do believe that quesadillas and boxing are two great Latin passions. However, mixing both of them in a gift just doesn't seem right. It actually makes me sad to see such a great world champion promoting melting cheese. I'd rather see him fighting a bear in a ring. Or maybe Chuck Norris. Yeah, that would be awesome!

All I want from Chuck Norris is to see him fighting (like in the good old days). But that's it. His macho awesomeness is not my idea of something worth reading about.

A personalized keepsake box? That's a nice touch. Useful to put my friend's number who gave it me in to make sure not to call him again.

Having said this, I like the idea of the app, and maybe it's not its fault. This could be like when you listen to your own voice recorded and you can't believe you sound like that. Now if you'll excuse me, gotta go. I need to urgently revise all the info and pics I have posted on my Facebook profile.

Ted Royer, ECD Droga5
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

South Park Bigger, Longer, Uncut

The Simpsons: The Complete 14th Season; Christmas with the Simpsons

The Daily Show with Jon Stewart Presents Earth

Blood Into Wine


"Pretty much a dead-on accurate want list. Although I haven't watched the Simpsons in years. Also, I already have half of this stuff. How can it tell someone not to buy duplicates? Anyway, very fun. "

Eric Silver,CCO, Amalgamated
Shopycat Gift Suggestions:

The Who Ultimate Collection

Fuel Blu-Ray

Hunger The Complete Second Season

Susan Boyle: Someone to Watch Over Me.


The Susan Boyle portion, while true, must be qualified with the footnote that I only listen to her when drunk or gardening.

Lars Bastholm, CCO, Cheil USA
Etsy Gift Suggestions:

1975 Wooden Coca-Cola 12 to 16 Bottle Carrier

BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Vinyl Record Wall Clock (Born in the U.S.A.)

Rocky Horror Picture Show Frankenfurter Ring


I'm reminded a bit of the Jimmy Fallon stunt, where they punk'd some kids and gave them things like an onion and a juicebox for Christmas instead of the gifts they were expecting. The look of disappointment on their little faces was hilarious.

While I'm a big fan of both Bruce Springsteen and The Rocky Horror Picture Show and have certainly drunk my share of Cokes over the years, the 'fan fiction' treatment given to them on Etsy is probably for a more discerning taste than mine. And much like 'Jaws 2' was toothless (sorry), certain things should not be 'line extended', 're-imagined' or 'sequelized'.

So I'd probably prefer an onion and a juicebox over these suggestions, actually.

William Gelner, 180LA
Etsy Gift Suggestions:

Texas Longhorn Charger

Guitar Pick with Johnny Cash Quote

Unique Circuit Board Alarm Clock from a Recycled Computer Hard Drive


These bot picked reco's are much better than some of the ones I get from other sites. Like the Sansabelt pants ad staring me in the face right now from our friends at Facebook. I particularly dig the Johnny Cash guitar pick. That's boss. And I'd love it. Hint hint. Anyone?

Jason Zada, Director, Tool
Etsy Gift Suggestions:

True Blood Photomanipulation your FACE on Sookie's-Rolling Stone

Bloodbath Dexter Gift Bloodslide Soap

Porcelain Smokey the Bear Fireman Box


Hah. I've liked all of these things on Facebook. Two HBO shows and Smokey Bear (which I directed the last few years of commercials for).

Most Popular
In this article: