Magazine Circulation-Fraud Case Enters Plea Negotiations

Accused Consultant at 'Laptop' Also Worked for Other Titles

By Published on .

NEW YORK ( -- One of the publishing executives accused of circulation fraud at Laptop magazine has entered plea negotiations with the U.S. Justice Department, court documents filed in the case show.

Related Stories:
Feds Charge Two Publishing Execs With Circulation Fraud
Sting Operation Snares 'Laptop' Publisher and Circulation Director
BPA Offers to Certify Subscription Agents
In Wake of Scandals, Audit Bureau Competitor Will Verify Third-Party Sources
'Minneapolis Star-Tribune' Settles Advertiser Lawsuit
Agrees To Pay $55,000 To Plaintiffs That Accused Paper of Inflating Circulation
Meredith Reveals Circulation Problems at Acquired Titles
Says Any Pre-Purchase Magazine Liabilities Are Gruner & Jahr's Problem
Kliger Calls for Magazines to Come Clean on Circ
Urges Industry to Eliminate Anything That Has the Potential to Mislead
Time Inc. Circulation Records Subpoenaed
150 Clients and Advertisers Notified of Federal Investigation
Circulation Scandal Engulfs More Magazines
Millions of 'Paid' Copies Disqualified; Media Buyers Angry

Deal likely
Proceedings regarding the executive, John Jay Annis, are on hold through Jan. 30 while the parties try to hammer out a deal, which Judge Steven M. Gold has indicated he considers likely.

The U.S. attorney's office for the Eastern District of New York, which has been investigating circulation practices since schemes by Newsday and Hoy to inflate their numbers became public, secured the arrests of Edward D. Brown, president-publisher, Bedford Communications, and Mr. Annis, Bedford's circulation director, last October.

Bogus distribution
Prosecutors accused the pair of scheming to inflate circulation at Laptop magazine by hiring a distributor to accept 15,000 copies that they would claim as paid circulation -- whether or not they were ever distributed. The distributor they hired was really an undercover postal inspector, prosecutors said.

It is unclear what a plea arrangement would mean to the circulation investigation. According to the Bedford Web site, Mr. Annis serves as a circulation consultant to "several other publishing companies," so he may have information of interest to prosecutors about magazines beyond Laptop. That could explain the surprising effort by the government to arrange an elaborate sting on executives at Bedford, a relatively small target.

No comment
The lead prosecutor on the case, Jonathan Edward Davis, declined to comment on any such speculation or other facets of the negotiations. An attorney for Mr. Annis did not respond to a message seeking comment.

The U.S. attorney's office has also subpoenaed Time Inc. for information on that company's bulk-distribution programs. Time Inc. disclosed the subpoena in September and said it was complying.

But a plea deal may produce nothing more than testimony against Mr. Brown or a quicker resolution of the case.

Mr. Brown's status is also unclear. After the original order for his arrest and a reported not-guilty plea, court documents do not mention him again and do not list an attorney for him. Mr. Brown did not return a call seeking comment.

Most Popular
In this article: