When the NBA Finals concluded on Monday, fans were locked out of the No. 1 community for basketball discussions on Reddit, r/NBA. It was the most important basketball game of the year, but the NBA subreddit was among hundreds of forums that switched to private to protest Reddit’s new policies surrounding third-party apps.

Subreddits for Apple, Disney, “Star Wars” and “Star Trek” were among the message boards devoted to mainstream brands that went dark and even extended their protests beyond the original 48 hours.

Now, Reddit executives want a return to normalcy, which could pit Reddit’s everyday visitors against holdout moderators who control the rules of the communities. The moderators decide whether a subreddit stays private, and average members don’t always get much say on community rules. When a subreddit goes private, the community is locked to unapproved members.

Meanwhile, the brands have no control over how the communities operate. The NBA, NFL, Disney and others, for example, do not run the most visible subreddits dedicated to their respective brands. 

The Reddit revolt so far has had a limited effect on advertisers, said Jen Wong, Reddit’s chief operating officer, in an interview Thursday.

In some ways the protest has helped drive more traffic to Reddit, boosting impressions on campaigns, Wong said. At some points, traffic surged because of interest in the protests, according to Wong. A few advertisers did postpone “takeover” ad campaigns to wait for the protests to calm down, Wong said, but declined to name the brands. A brand that did run a takeover “overdelivered significantly,” according to Wong, adding that of all the communities that serve ads on Reddit, about 15% went private.

The protest began after moderators of the communities became upset by Reddit’s new policy charging some developers for access to its application programming interface (API). The costs could force some popular third-party apps to close, and moderators and “power users” often access Reddit through these third-party apps.

“They are important to Reddit. We’re talking to them,” said Wong. “We’re having a public and private dialog with moderators. We’re trending toward returning, having the protests return to normalcy.”

On Thursday, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman, who has been a target of massive criticism from hardcore Reddit users, suggested a path forward. Reddit could empower the members of subreddits to make decisions on whether a community stays on lockdown. As it stands the independent moderators have all the power, but there are signs that rank-and-file Reddit users don’t always agree with the protests. Huffman gave several interviews on Thursday during which he compared moderators to “landed gentry”—meaning they have tremendous say over prime real estate on Reddit, such as r/NBA, r/Disney, r/Apple.

“A lot of communities have come back at this point and that’s driven by moderators, and moderator sentiment,” Wong said. “And then a lot of users are ready to come back, too, I think. People are supportive of a protest and discussion, but they’re ready to come back.”

Roxy Young, Reddit’s chief marketing and consumer experience officer, has been handling the private outreach to subreddit moderators to explain the pricing changes to the API. By Wednesday, some subreddits returned, but others such as r/NBA stayed locked. The “Star Wars” subreddit made its content public, but it limited the ability of fans to create new posts, which was still the case as of Friday morning. The “Star Trek” community limited new posts and it was pointing visitors to a new website for discussions. 

The protest serves as another reminder about how Reddit can be a volatile place. The users are deeply engaged in their communities and sometimes knowledgeable, but they are also quick to organize against perceived slights. Brands that misstep on Reddit can become the target of backlashes. For instance, in February, Oatly, the oat-based dairy brand, placed a cheeky ad on Reddit and left the comments open. The ad got no upvotes, which is how users show they like a post, and it received 2,600 mostly negative comments.

The most popular forums related to brands can be a resource for marketers at those brands. The Reddit communities are comprised of the most devoted fans—and critics—of products. The communities for shows and movies are filled with binge-watchers who go to Reddit to discuss streaming TV. An extended lockdown could force fans to look for new communities either within Reddit, or outside of it.

“People want to talk about 'Star Wars,' and it is going to find an outlet in a community,” Wong said. “And we see communities regenerate, or fork, all the time, for a variety of reasons. Communities do regenerate very quickly.”

Reddit is getting ready for its second straight big year at the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity in France, which starts on Monday. Huffman, Wong and Young will attend. Since announcing the API changes, Huffman has been a target for irate Reddit users to post about their frustrations.

Wong said that there have been misconceptions about how the API pricing will affect developers. Most apps will not have to pay anything, because they don’t meet the data thresholds, Wong said. Developers pay for how many “calls” their services make to the API.

“More than 98% of apps do not pay and will continue to access the Data API for free so long as apps are not monetized and are below our published data-usage threshold,” Reddit said on Thursday.

For high-use developers, they will pay 24 cents for every thousand calls to the API. Until now there were apps that made hundreds of millions of calls to the API a day for free, according to Reddit. At 24 cents per thousand calls, 100 million calls would cost $24,000, under the new pricing model. 

Reddit is trying to develop its ad business, and there are apps that create versions of the site that don’t run ads. As of Thursday, 80% of the top 5,000 communities were open, according to Reddit. Communities were coalescing in new places, too, after popular destinations shut their doors. For instance, after the NBA championships on Monday, when fans couldn’t go to the NBA subreddit, they flooded r/DenverNuggets. That is the local forum, independent of r/NBA, devoted to the Nuggets. Other smaller NBA communities also saw more conversations.

“During a period, where things go private,” Wong said, “the feed starts to surface other communities that sometimes don’t get as much visibility, which is great for discovering.”

Some subreddits defied the protests. For instance, the r/steak community, with 511,000 members, was open for grilling pics throughout.

~ ~ ~
CLARIFICATION: About 15% of all of the communities that serve ads on Reddit went private.