Few brand collabs have the power to surprise in the age of Peeps-flavored Pepsi and Tesla tequila, but the partnership between Chipotle Mexican Grill and e.l.f. Cosmetics that first flourished last year proved to be a headline-making exception.

See all of Ad Age's 2021 Small Agency Award winners here.

Courtesy of New York's Day One Agency—charged with Chipotle’s social and cultural creative duties for the past four years—the idea to combine a makeup brand with a Mexican food chain arose after noticing that Chipotle and e.l.f. were two of the hottest brands on TikTok. The surprise pairing made their debut in May 2020 with a limited-edition cosmetics collection that sold out in minutes, proving the collaboration’s staying power among young, social-savvy consumers.

In March of this year, the brands doubled down on their relationship with an eyeshadow palette of burrito-inspired colors along with a host of other makeup products, sold by both brands on their websites and on virtual shopping platform NTWRK. And while the cruelty-free cosmetics collection was the star of the duo’s most recent promotional streak, Chipotle also got in on the custom product action, launching a vegan “Eyes. Chips. Face. Bowl.” that was available to patrons earlier this year.