'Can I Be Gay in the Army?' British Military Answers in Controversial Campaign
Campaign by Karmarama Has Been Accused of Political Correctness
Editor's Pick
The British Army this weekend debuted a major new campaign that focuses on "belonging," aimed at boosting falling recruitment by showing all recruits are welcome. Addressing sensitive issues of sexuality, religion and emotional doubts that might hinder people from joining the military, the ads, by Karmarama, have already been deemed controversial, with some asking whether they are catering to the "snowflake" generation by being overly politically correct.
The campaign includes a series of online animations, created with production house We Are Royale, that address questions such as "Can I be gay in the Army?" (seen here), "Can I practice my faith in the Army?" and "What if I get emotional in the Army?" Another is voiced by a female soldier who says she worried about whether she would be listened to. The films are based on the stories of real-life soldiers.
These are accompanied by several TV spots, which address similar scenarios: we see a soldier getting emotional reading a note from home, a Muslim soldier praying while in the field, and a group of soldiers joke around on a military aircraft. Another soldier faces his fear of being unfit by doing pull-ups, while another spot features a black soldier who discovers that the Army means he will be "listened to." All carry the tagline "this is belonging." The live action spots are directed by Academy directors Frederic Planchon and Si & Ad.
Details of the campaign were leaked last week to the British media, prompting a range of opinions. Some former soliders have accused the campaign of being too politcally correct, while an article by Catherine Bennett in the Observer says the campaign "fails to mention poor pay and conditions and the need to kill." But according to the BBC, General Sir Nick Carter, head of the Army, responded to criticism by saying the campaign reflects the U.K.'s changing demography.
Credits
- Date
- Jan 16, 2018
- Agency :
- Karmarama
- Brand :
- Barnardo's
- Client :
- Barnardo's
- Chief Creative Officer :
- Nik Studzinski
- Executive Creative Director :
- Adam Kean
- Executive Creative Director :
- Dickie Connell
- Executive Creative Director :
- Brian Williams
- Creative Director :
- Imogen Tazzyman
- Creative Director :
- James Rooke
- Creative Team :
- Meigan Brown
- Creative Team :
- Tobias Owen
- Creative Planner :
- Matthew Waksman
- Agency Producer :
- Rebecca Hunter
- Agency Producer :
- Matthew Towell
- Business Lead :
- Charlotte Hodgson
- Account Director :
- Will Bright
- Account Manager :
- Sophie Coyne
- Account Executive :
- Charlotte Allcock
- Production Company :
- Academy Films
- Prayer and Pull Up :
- Frederic Planchon
- 'Voice, Letter, Buckaroo' :
- Si & Ad
- Producer :
- Medb Riordan
- Production Manager :
- Gemma Priggen
- Director, Photography :
- Justin Brown
- First Assistant Director :
- Jim Cole
- Offline Editor :
- Sam Rice-Edwards
- Edit Company :
- The Assembly Rooms
- Visual Effects Post House :
- Nineteen Twenty
- Visual Effects Supervisor :
- Ludo Fealy
- Visual Effects Producer :
- Hannah Ruddleston
- Colorist :
- Jean-Clement Soret
- Color :
- MPC
- Sound Designer :
- Sam Ashwell
- Sound Company :
- 750
- Music Company :
- Soundtree
- Production Company :
- We Are Royale
Need a credit fix? Contact the Creativity Editors
Related work

Barnardo's: This storybook aims to reassure children anxious about the pandemic

Barnardo's: Snarling hyenas symbolize bullies in this spot by kids' charity Barnardo's

Barnardo's: Land Rover is '70 years young' in anniversary ad with lots of kids but not a car in sight
