Contextual targeting isn’t enough—marketers need fewer, smarter ads

For years, marketers have believed that more choice means more power—that a broader range of price points and product options gives consumers more value for their money. In fact, what time and more research has shown is that non-curated choice often dissolves value rather than enhancing it. The challenge isn’t an excess of options—it’s failing to present the right ones at the right moment. And sometimes, the best choice is no choice at all. How do you decide? E-commerce platforms and advertisers often prioritize quantity over quality and lean heavily into contextually targeted ads, thinking that they are ensuring that content aligns with a user’s interests. Instead of guiding customers toward meaningful decisions, these distractions lead to cognitive overload, transaction delays and even cart abandonment. Also read: Ad targeting failures—why brands are missing their intended audiences True success in targeting comes from ads that are not just contextually appropriate but also desired. However, 51% of consumers feel deprived when presented with too few relevant choices. This deprivation effect is even more pronounced in high-stakes decisions and proves that consumers don’t necessarily want fewer options—they want the right ones at the right time. This applies equally to advertising: A well-timed, highly relevant ad enhances the experience, while an out-of-place or unnecessary ad diminishes it. The power of smarter targeting For marketers, the answer isn’t to eliminate choice but to refine how it’s structured, ensuring that customers see the right choices at the precise moment they need them. Instead of relying on broad demographics or past behavior, real-time decisioning uses immediate signals of intent to serve hyper-relevant offers. High-intent buyers can be guided toward complementary offers that enhance their purchase, while unnecessary distractions for those in the final stages of conversion can be minimized to maintain a frictionless experience. Achieving this requires more than just static personalization—it demands real-time decisioning powered by first-party data. More from Ad Age: Contextual targeting ensures that ads align with the surrounding content, but it is one-dimensional and doesn’t account for the full context of a shopper’s behavior, interests and needs. Effective decisioning ensures that the right ad (or no ad) is shown at the right time. This dynamic responsiveness is what separates effective advertising from wasted ad spend. In fact, Forrester Research estimates that 37% of ad spend is wasted due to imprecise targeting. Applying the same 37% inefficiency rate to digital advertising suggests that around $190 billion may be ineffectively allocated. Using first-party data to make smarter choices As third-party cookies phase out, brands must rethink how they collect and activate data to drive conversions. Instead of relying on broad audience segments built from third-party sources, businesses can now leverage first-party insights—behavioral patterns, transaction history and real-time engagement signals—to make smarter, in-the-moment recommendations. Rather than overwhelming customers with an exhaustive list of options, brands can refine how choices are structured. By analyzing signals such as browsing patterns, purchase intent and contextual clues in real-time, brands can surface offers that feel relevant and timely. Also read: How Meta’s new AI ad model recommends creative for marketers For example, if a shopper is browsing high-performance running shoes, a traditional approach might serve them contextually related product recommendation. However, with real-time decisioning powered by first-party data, the system can instantly recognize their preferences, identify their past purchases and suggest hyper-relevant offers that may have nothing to do with sports becoming additive to the flow of their shopping journey. is The future is contextual scarcity Instead of presenting customers with a flood of irrelevant options, businesses must harness data to refine the purchase experience, ensuring every recommendation enhances the journey rather than complicating it. That will ensure they experience a seamless, intuitive journey where every interaction feels tailored, timely and valuable—driving higher conversion rates, stronger loyalty and a competitive edge in the cookieless era. The future of commerce lies not in overwhelming customers with choices but in knowing when to offer them, when to refine them and when to step back entirely. As spending on contextual advertising is projected to reach $562 billion by 2030, the brands that succeed won’t be those that offer the most choices but those that understand what, when and how to present them. And don’t forget—sometimes the best choice is to show nothing at all.

Contextual targeting isn’t enough—marketers need fewer, smarter ads

Featured Stories