Google did not share specifics about how AI played a role in its national ad, details for which have not been released yet.
However, AI was largely not a necessity for many brands this year. Seventeen brands, including Taco Bell, Coors Light, Reese’s and DoorDash, told Ad Age that they did not use the technology at any stage in the development of their Super Bowl ads.
Inside the making of Reese’s volcanic Super Bowl commercial
Why don’t brands want to use AI for Super Bowl ads?
Some brands could be keeping AI at an arm’s length this Super Bowl because they fear backlash from their fellow marketers, said Kevin McTigue, clinical professor of marketing at Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management. And they would have plenty of recent examples to back up their concerns about generating AI outrage. For example, last year, Toys R Us used OpenAI’s video tool, Sora, for an ad that was widely panned by the creative community. And for the holidays, Coca-Cola aired an AI-generated TV ad that also drew a polarizing response from members of the ad industry.
Super Bowl audiences, too, have shown a distaste toward content they interpreted as having AI’s fingerprints. For one of its ads during last year’s game, the “He Gets Us” campaign drew ire on social media for appearing to feature AI-generated imagery, even though the technology was not involved.
Doritos barred AI-generated content from being used in its fan contest, in which one fan-created ad was selected to be this year’s official spot.
“We wanted this truly to be something that highlighted creators’ love for the brand and for creating, and we felt like to make that a fair platform for everyone that might submit an ad, we decided that AI was something we didn’t want to be used,” said Tina Mahal, SVP of marketing at PepsiCo Foods North America, during Ad Age’s Super Bowl Playbook. PepsiCo is the parent company of Doritos.
In addition to the 17 companies that told Ad Age they did not use AI, another 14 brands declined to comment for this story, including Nerds, Dove and Liquid Death. This hesitation could be a sign that marketers are worried about the optics of using AI to create their ads because the technology still presents a PR problem, said Craig Elimeliah, chief creative officer at agency Code and Theory.
“Brands are keeping quiet, not because AI isn’t involved, but because they don’t want it to be the story,” Elimeliah said.
How are agencies using AI for Super Bowl ads?
More so than brands, agencies were keen to use AI for their Super Bowl efforts.
Ad agency Monks used AI to pitch ideas to shopping rewards app Fetch for a livestream that will run alongside Fetch’s official spot, said Adam Strom, Monks’ group creative director. Fetch has a national commercial, created in-house, that will send people to the livestream on its app, where it is giving away $1.2 million. Monks tapped into its proprietary AI hub, Runway’s text-to-video tool and Adobe Firefly to show Fetch ideas for the livestream. For example, the agency generated images in the brand’s purple and yellow colors to make its ideas feel more bespoke, Strom said. Monks also generated images to precisely show lighting and prop teams the scenes it wanted to create in the livestream.
“AI makes the right idea easier to get through,” said Strom. Still, Fetch did not use AI in the production process of the actual spot, a brand spokesperson told Ad Age.
Pinnacle Advertising used image generator Midjourney to storyboard its ad for WeatherTech, a spokesperson for the brand told Ad Age. The CGI-filled spot follows a group of women in their 70s wreaking havoc during a road trip. WeatherTech itself did not use AI in the production process, the spokesperson said.
AI also lent an advantage to agencies when they were pressed for time. In January, when Fetch wanted Monks to be ready for a test of the livestream, shortening the time it had to complete the concept, Monks used its AI hub to quickly get its creatives on the same page, Strom said.
AI is especially helpful during the early stages of developing ads when agencies often need to act quickly and pitch brands on ideas, said FCB’s Sussman.
“I imagine a lot of agencies used AI to get them to their Super Bowl brief,” Sussman said. FCB New York, which worked on this year’s Super Bowl ads for Pringles and Budweiser, did not use AI at any stage in the process, Sussman said.
How will AI show up in Super Bowl ads?
Last year’s Super Bowl ads referenced AI more frequently than those of the previous year, and this year that number will be even higher, Fox’s ad sales leader Evans told Ad Age last week.
AI will be a central focus of Meta’s ads, which promote the company’s Ray-Ban smart glasses. Chris Hemsworth, Chris Pine and Kris Jenner wear the glasses and query Meta’s AI assistant with the phrase “Hey Meta” in an ad released Monday.