Advertising has long been an industry run by white men. And, increasingly, older white men who, with certainty, miss the good old days of advertising. There isn’t a single female CEO at the six holding companies that control 75 percent of ad spend. And, until a few years ago, only 3 percent of creative directors were women. So, it’s little wonder the dynamics of the “Mad Men” era still exist.
We have seen some improvement in the past few years. Many men have come to understand how diversity creates a more productive team and more powerful results; or have at least wizened up to how the make-up of their company should appear. But giving women board seats or executive titles isn’t enough. It’s about changing the general attitude toward women, and the systemic cultural problem where women’s issues, ideas and priorities aren’t seen as valuable—or certainly not as valuable as those of their male counterparts.
In fact, the discrimination is so deeply embedded in our industry (and society as a whole) that it’s happening right before our eyes without us even really registering it.
Right now, the discussion we’re having about influencer marketing is whether it’s “legitimate,” a “fad,” or “wasteful”—all while it continues to be one of the best-performing verticals within advertising. Is it a coincidence that the influencer marketing industry, which is 77 percent female and run for women, by women, has been consistently marginalized as invalid and fraudulent? Or is it more likely that the old guard doesn't understand it (and perhaps feels threatened by it) because all they see are young, “good looking” women who they don’t take seriously—and yet, who keep gaining traction? They dismiss influencers again and again, using their long-held power to deem this domain not just unimportant and irrelevant, but fraudulent and ineffective, which is simply just not true.
“Aren’t influencers just pretty people?” the head of a top creative shop recently bemused me. And certainly, that’s often what men see. That women who are talking about bronzer or facial rollers are simple-minded. This ignorant generalization has created an environment where influencers are not only undervalued, but deeply underestimated.